|
| My God Can Beat the Shit Out of Your God For discussing any and all religious viewpoints. Intolerance will not be tolerated. Keeping your sense of humor is required. Posting messages about theological paradoxes is encouraged. |

2003-07-04, 02:18
|
|
Regular
|
|
Certainly NOT at Fort Mead ha!
|
|
How does the Cathlic belief differ from Protestant? Could someone explain about the different rituals and rites? or suggest a good site?
|

2003-07-04, 04:38
|
|
Regular
|
|
Pittsburgh, PA USA
|
|
As a former Catholic, I have a good deal of info for you. First Catholics believe that the eucharist literally transforms into the body and blood of Christ, whereas protestants believe that this is only symbolic. This is called transubstanciation (sp?). Catholics also believe that Peter, the first pope was ordained by Jesus, himself, and therefor every pope down to the priests, are all ordained, indirectly, by Christ. Catholics believe that priests have a direct link to God and can do all kinds of neat stuff, like blessings, and forgiveness of sins, exorcisms, etc. Catholics place faith in saints, and the virgin Mary and believe by praying to these entities, they can do the same kinds of things that only God or Jesus can do for the protestants (which also allows for easy syncritism with African and other polytheistic systems, thus Santeria). Catholics believe that good works and repentence before death will guarantee a ticket to heaven, as will the good word of a priest). Catholic priests are forbidden to fuck, or even jack off (although the Church doesn't seem to want to prosecute or persecute those that don't follow this). Catholics also use a slightly earlier form of the bible, and also determined (through various early councils) all the books that the protestants got to pick from.
There are many other differences, why don't you search on google?
|

2003-07-04, 07:35
|
|
Regular
|
|
Great british empire
|
|
Quote:
quote:Originally posted by NChSh:
As a former Catholic, I have a good deal of info for you. First Catholics believe that the eucharist literally transforms into the body and blood of Christ, whereas protestants believe that this is only symbolic. This is called transubstanciation (sp?). Catholics also believe that Peter, the first pope was ordained by Jesus, himself, and therefor every pope down to the priests, are all ordained, indirectly, by Christ. Catholics believe that priests have a direct link to God and can do all kinds of neat stuff, like blessings, and forgiveness of sins, exorcisms, etc. Catholics place faith in saints, and the virgin Mary and believe by praying to these entities, they can do the same kinds of things that only God or Jesus can do for the protestants (which also allows for easy syncritism with African and other polytheistic systems, thus Santeria). Catholics believe that good works and repentence before death will guarantee a ticket to heaven, as will the good word of a priest). Catholic priests are forbidden to fuck, or even jack off (although the Church doesn't seem to want to prosecute or persecute those that don't follow this). Catholics also use a slightly earlier form of the bible, and also determined (through various early councils) all the books that the protestants got to pick from.
There are many other differences, why don't you search on google?
|
This is a good answer, but in my country the difference is mostly political and separatist, leading to extreme bigotry from both sides,
As far as im conserned, protestantism started in europe as a result of rebelion against the vatican corruption, and the pope requesting money before he would grant forgivness.
Protestantism began in britain however, because Henry the 8th wanted to divorce his wife and remmary
Henry the 8Th was a murdering bastard
|

2003-07-04, 14:44
|
|
|
Quote:
quote:Originally posted by mister pointyhat:
Protestantism began in britain however, because Henry the 8th wanted to divorce his wife and remmary
|
I always thought there was a difference between Anglicism and Protestantism.
Maybe I'm wrong. Clarification would be appreciated.
|

2003-07-11, 01:03
|
|
Regular
|
|
Las Vegas, Nevada, US
|
|
I come form a similar situation as NChSh. I grew up protestant and became catholic as an adult. From my experience there is almost no difference between the two groups in what they believe about God. The dogma of the catholic church is spelled out in the Nicene Creed, excluding a few things about Mary.
As far as the rituals go, there is quite a great deal of difference. The catholic church does the same thing every week without a great deal of variation. Some protestant churches operate similarly, but a lot of them have no structured format. I have been to several different denominations' worship sevices and it was a total crap shoot as to what I was going to get.
|

2003-07-11, 01:08
|
|
Regular
|
|
Las Vegas, Nevada, US
|
|
Quote:
quote:Originally posted by TigerJK:
I always thought there was a difference between Anglicism and Protestantism.
Maybe I'm wrong. Clarification would be appreciated.
|
Anglicans are almost the exact same thing as catholics, except the King of England is the head of the anglican church and the pope is the head of the catholic church.
Well, Jesus is the head of the church, but until he returns, the king and the pope are trying, unsuccessfully, to fill His shoes.
|

2003-07-11, 01:59
|
|
|
Catholics believe in not being giant pains in the ass that come to your door asking if you have found Jesus.
I may be wrong though.
|

2003-07-11, 03:54
|
|
|
Quote:
quote:Originally posted by Gray Reaver:
Catholics believe in not being giant pains in the ass that come to your door asking if you have found Jesus.
I may be wrong though.
|
Eh, back in the Middle Ages the church would send priests door to door selling timed forgiveness for money.
|

2003-07-11, 07:00
|
|
|
Catholics believe whatever the Catholic "menacing pantheon of evil" Church tells them to.
|

2003-07-11, 23:50
|
|
Regular
|
|
Las Vegas, Nevada, US
|
|
You make it sound like catholics have no capacity for independent thought.
|
Posting Rules
|
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off
|
|
|
All times are GMT. The time now is 11:12.
|
|